RSS Feed

Math Finals

Is it so terribly, terribly wrong that I am using my child as a kind of Blog Topic Magic Eight Ball? It worked once before – I couldn’t think of anything I wanted to write about, I asked him as he left for the day, and he gave me an idea. I know that I can count on him to come up with something that is not depressing, that is absolutely not whatever I had already considered and rejected, and that is, in most cases, not the product of even the faintest husk of a thought. (We call that “whimsical”). Today, he said I should write about “math finals,” and so I will.

You will no doubt be shocked to learn that he has a math final today, or, more accurately, the second part of a two-part episode of a math final. (The exciting conclusion in which Rational Number breaks the bonds imposed by his evil opposite, Pi Face, and saves the fractious hostages). He has been “studying” after a fashion, a process that seems mainly to involve total avoidance until fifteen minutes before bedtime, followed by hysterical pleas for help from his father. No one in their right mind would ask me to help them study for a math final. I am, in that context, not only non-essential parental personnel, but a potentially damaging influence, quarantined in my office until someone needs to know what a “gerund” is. I did raise my stock the other night, when, hearing a discussion about expressing the fact that some-number-or-other in an equation might be more than zero, but was not, necessarily more than zero, I yelled from my office that they needed the “greater to or equal sign.”

They decided that I was right. Never mind that the only reason I remember the existence of the “greater than or equal to” sign is that when I first learned about it, it reminded me very much of the kind of eyes drawn on the figures adorning Egyptian tombs. I used to draw a little dot in the small, closed end (the apex?) of the wedge part of the sign to make them into eyes. Sometimes I got distracted and drew people on the edges of my worksheets, legs and feet impossibly separate and parallel, heads adorned with jeweled bands, eyes expressing the dark mysteries of the greater than or equal to sign.

Back to the math finals. I do not remember having final exams earlier than middle school, at which time they had some kind of hip, 70s name like “Unit Comprehension Review.” I rarely comprehended the unit. I got hopelessly lost some time around fourth grade; I think long division was the last thing I really understood. Well, that isn’t entirely true: I remember bits and pieces of things that I somehow managed to learn. I know my away around a fraction, and I can reduce, find least common denominators, add, subtract, multiply and divide them with great panache. I was actually a very good geometry student, and pretty good at the “story problems” that seemed to plague other people. Comforted, I think, by the inclusion of actual words in a problem, I could get from them the essence of what was called for, and turn it into numbers and signs. Sometimes, coming in from that kind of success, I could even solve it.

Aside from geometry, high school was a wasteland of non-feasance in my arithmetical, or more accurately, algebraic education. My freshman year, an “experimental math program” in Algebra I, a soft-covered, fake-looking textbook, a frustrated teacher, a curriculum so unfamiliar that my father couldn’t help me any more. “You are so smart,” the teacher said to me in the middle of the year, “I don’t understand why you don’t do better work.” My grades heading south for the winter, for the year, forever. The finals looked, like all other quizzes and homework: pages of numbers and symbols and a lot of “x” and “y” stuff. I had vague ideas about what I might do with them, and usually started out optimistic and willing to try (at least the first year) but began to hyperventilate and give up after three or four problems. I dissociated, I looked at the page and squinted until I saw patterns. I tried again, and it wasn’t any better. Eventually, I got to the “what are they going to do to me, anyway?” stage and sat, polite and giving all appearances of being focused, until I could turn the test in and forget about it until the sledgehammer moment when it was returned to me with some terrible grade and a scrawled indictment of my intellect in red marker.

It was no better in Algebra II. It was worse. Sines, cosines, curlicues that looked like fancy earrings, or a new kind of snack food. I was mostly interested in hearing stories from Janie Mancato, who had lost her virginity at lunch one day (at the home of her boyfriend, who lived right near the high school, and had a car) and returned to us most 4th hours thereafter, breathless and flushed with her new experiences. Even if I had been interested in algebra, it could not have competed with that kind of show.

A conversation with my Algebra II teacher:

Me: “Why does anybody need algebra? Do you use it in later life?”

Mr. D: “It is an important part of developing your ability to think logically. You won’t necessarily use algebra, per se, although some people will, but no matter what you do, it will be good for you to have the ability to solve problems in a logical way.”

Me: “Oh.”

The finals in that class were even worse. I had no idea what I was looking at, or what I was supposed to do. I am a good test-taker, and a fabulous bluffer, but there was no way to “game” an Algebra II test without so much as inhaling a faint whiff of trigonometry or the thing with the graphs and arrows. In addition to my impressive lack of comprehension, I felt guilty this time; I could not claim that this, like my failure in Algebra I was the fault of The Man who had forced me to fail despite my pathetic attempts to learn something. This was all my fault, my fault for not paying attention in class, my fault for failing to study or do my homework, my fault for failing to avail myself of the help offered from many sources. I failed. Lots. I got a “D,” the worst grade I ever got anywhere. It went on my permanent record. I became “a problem like Maria” (only less charming and unable to sing) for my guidance counselor, trying to reconcile my status as a National Merit semifinalist with That Grade. What college would admit me with that grade? How would it be explained?

He, and everyone else heaved a sigh of relief when I announced my plans to go into music, where no one cared about a “D” in Algebra II. There was never another math class; although it might have been amusing to see what I came up with in Calculus, no one suggested that I try it. There was no math at the Conservatory, and when, later, I transferred to a fine liberal arts school, my advisor gently advised me not to take any math classes, because “it didn’t seem to go too well for you in high school.”

Here’s the thing, though. If I had it to do over, I could do it, and do it well. I have a brain that seems to be evenly split between the logical part that makes sounds and persuasive legal arguments, and the creative part that wants to play with words, and colors, and take a nap, maybe, and see if my face changes if I stare at the mirror for a really long time. That logical part does not amuse me nearly as much as the other part, and if I had to have some kind of Sybilectomy I would definitely tell the neurosurgeon to cut all the strings that make the logical thing happen. For now, though, it is a part of me, and it works, and it didn’t die no matter how hard I tried to kill it in high school. I am not Jack Kerouac. I am a person who can figure out how many boxes of spaghetti we need for the spaghetti supper, subtract the number of parents who will blow of the request, and divide up their contribution evenly among the parents who will actually help.

I call that algebra.

Photo Credits:

Algebra Test:

“Find X:”


About imagineannie

I feel like I'm fifteen - does that count? I'm lots of things, I get paid to be the Managing Editor for a local news publication, and I love my job. I am also inordinately fond of reading, animals (I have four), elephants, owls, hedgehogs writing, tramping in the woods, cooking India, Ireland, England, avocado toast, Sherlock Holmes, Harry Potter, Little Women, Fun Home, Lumber Janes, Fangirl, magic, Neil Gaiman, Jane Austen, YA books, not YA books, classical music, Salinger (OMG SALINGER), Brahms, key lime pie, indie music, podcasts, sleeping in, road trips, marmalade, museums, bookstores, the Oxford comma, BBC, The Miss Fisher Mysteries, birdwatching, seashells, kombucha, and stickers. Not a huge fan of chewing gum, jazz, trucker hats or dystopian and/or post-apolcalyptic fiction (but I'll try anything).

16 responses »

  1. I hope Janie’s parents don’t read this.

  2. Despite the fact that this subject matter makes me break into hives, I’m still laughing at the photo: find x: here it is! 🙂

    I thought I was done with math after the sine and cosine (my personal “crash of ’78”), but then came statistics as a prerequisite for grad. school (and out came the tears)!

  3. Tammy, they did not. The closest I got was the math required for Tax I, which was much easier than anything I did in high school.

  4. yes, the two day math exam….Daniel had to cram his studying in before his band concert last night. Not great timing… I laughed that you were good at story problems and geometry, the two things in math I couldn’t do…my brain is much more suited to do the algebra. Good luck to Sam today.

  5. Math–hated it. Strange, but I did well with Geometry, too. Something about the clear application and usefulness of this area of math. However, when it got to the weird, abstract formulas (formulae?) of Algebra, I was holding on by my fingernails. I only passed with good grades because I always did my homework–my test results were abysmal as I obviously didn’t grasp the concepts. Full stop. From then on, I just played to my strengths. Your algebra image gives me a stomachache–just looking at it and remembering my past struggles. Good post.

    • You and me both, baby. I know I’ve covered some of this ground before, but having asked Sam for an idea (and been answered) I felt that I had to step up and take the challenge….

  6. I hate to be the one to blow the whistle (37 years late), but who were your 4th and 5th grade teachers at Wardcliff? Every person I know from there struggled when they hit middle school (yes, except for him, but he was a savant). I, myself, was taught by an affable man with a German name who never corrected the homework, and gave very few tests. Since the answers were in the back of the book, life was sweet. A certain 5th grade teacher had cancer for years, and they let her keep teaching (if you call it that), and yet I remember no math being assigned or done. I remember film strips and “The Electric Company” and lots of free reading. The sixth grade team despaired of us. What’s long division? What’s short division? Hmmm.

    I lucked out over you. Mr. D. called my parents a few weeks into Algebra 2 and suggested that I drop it. I kept falling asleep every time he turned to the board. 2nd hour. Monotone Man. I became school secretarial assistant instead. Now there’s skill development I could use later in life.

    My children know better than to ask me to check their math. 5th grade is beyond my limit. I am, however, a kick ass writing instructor, and very good with history, and dioramas, so I think forgiveness may follow.

    Another doppelganger note: I selected my major in college based on which ones did not require math. My advisor was from Haslett, and while taken aback, did the research so that I could slip through the College of Arts and Letters with two bachelor’s degrees that didn’t require me to darken the doorway of any room where cosigns or calculations were required. Blessed man.

    I’m glad to know I’m not alone, and applaud your thinking.

    And I can totally see Eric skating by by doing all his homework, can’t you? Such an upstanding straight A kind of kid. I had too much (negative) attitude to get away with that

    • My brother (below) responded to this pretty thoroughly. I do remember learning math at Wardcliff, mostly in 5th grade. Clearly, not enough (!). It was probably much harder to avoid math at M.S.U.; at Oberlin we had no requirements outside of those related to our majors, there were just “distribution requirements” which really weren’t requirememts at all, and were mostly designed, I think to make us take something outside of our major.

      Why didn’t he call my parents?!

  7. Esther . . . I think you hit it on the nosey.

    The ragged end of the 1970’s included some utterly cracked notions about teaching, and mathematics was one of the worst casualties. Imagine a curriculum designed by Jerry Garcia . . . .

    Which is tragic; like Bach, there is beauty in order, too.

    I didn’t really do well with math until I applied it to physics, where I forced myself onward. Statistics helped, too.

    Also, thanks be to Lucille Corkery, my 4th grade teacher. She was refreshingly old school; we diagrammed sentences, actually did problems, and were graded. In retrospect, outside of Gwen Stilwell, the only things that actually stuck with me in 6 years of elementary school.

    And those of us lucky enough to have had Larry Cockroft in high school –


    • Ah, this brings back the fact that I had every dumbass who ever taught in Okemos, and then M & D knew to avoid them when you came through. in all fairness, though, it wouldn’t have helped with the math thing. I was self-sabotaging from the start. I think that when I get old I may just take an algebra class so that I can do it right.

  8. Ann,

    The “magic 8 ball” method intriques me, I am so looking forward to the topics that pop out as his mind matures.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: