RSS Feed

The Human Cell Project

[Note: if you have landed here because you are searching the internet for pages actually related to “humans,” “cells” or actual science, you have made a terrible mistake. Hit the “back” arrow, and Godspeed].

It started as such things often do, with a casual remark. As I made change for sweaty, hormonally-scented tweens at the Middle School Activity Night, my friend Patty asked “what we were doing for the cell project.” This meant that there was a project, that her daughter had told her about the project a week ago, that my son was never going to tell me about the project, that it was a big deal, that we were not prepared, and that I would never get the whole story no matter what I did. I had been down this road before.

“I guess I don’t know about it, yet” I answered, hoping that Patty would save me as she had before. She, after all, has a child who is tidy of handwriting, aware of assignments, aware that she has a school-issued planner…she has a child who is a daughter.

“They have to make a human cell out of food. That’s really all I know.” This didn’t help. As I dispensed slices of pizza and unfurled dollars fished from tight jeans pockets, I imagined sending in a pepperoni pizza. The crust could be the cell wall, the sauce the endoplasmic reticulum, the cheese and pepperoni could be all that other stuff. All I could remember was mitochondria, “the power house of the cell.” The pizza could be delivered to his third hour science class, and it would be just like “Fast Times at Ridgemont High.” I could have my own Spicoli.

Mr. Hand: Am I hallucinating here? Just what in the hell do you think you’re doing?

Jeff Spicoli: Learning about Cuba, and having some food.

On Facebook, a lively conversation began among the mothers of the putative cell makers. Many had not received the assignment in written form, many found it ridiculous, no one was sure how the finished product was meant to get to school and stay safe until Science class, it was a problem that the teacher (not widely loved) had failed to post it online with other assignments. I sighed in relief. Everyone was in the same boat, and I could just do my best, or, rather Sam could do his best, and we could relax. In the course of the Facebook conversation my sister-in-law posted a link to instructions for making a human cell out of Jell-O. It looked perfect; candies suspended in the gelatin to give a 3-D picture of all of those Golgi Bodies and something-somes. I abandoned Spicoli and the pizza, and told Sam The Plan. We would go out and purchase all of the ingredients on the lengthy list, and then make the thing the night before it was due. For good measure, I made him recite the parts of a human cell, which he was able to do. I was smugly pleased.

The day before the assignment was due, I was a perfect storm of righteous indignation. Sam had told me that this teacher cared more about how things looked than anything else; his “Science Rap” had been down-graded because, although the group knew the relevant material, the music was not properly synced. I muttered to myself about how real learning was the important thing, and what about all of the parents who were living on Food Stamps and couldn’t afford extra food to make a human cell project? What about the parents who couldn’t drive their kids to school so that their projects didn’t get destroyed? How noble was I, going out after work to spend quite a lot of money on Jell-O and an assortment of candy just to please some out-of-touch teacher? I was on fire.

When we got home from the store, I made the Jell-O. The directions didn’t say how much Jell-O, only that it should be “light colored” so that the candy cell parts would show up. We made the pineapple gelatin we had bought, and it didn’t look like nearly enough to hold all of the requisite candy in suspension. We added the box of raspberry gelatin we had cadged from my sister-in-law, and it got very dark. While we let it set for an hour, I looked at my computer. The tide had turned. The children whose mothers had complained were making elaborate, thoughtful concoctions, decorating cakes, working alone or with their parents, making masterpieces. Sam was playing X-box while our too-dark bag of Jell-O failed to thicken in an hour, in an hour and a half, in two hours. I put it in the freezer.

At two hours, after it was already pretty much bed time, we began to follow the instructions about inserting various candies into the Jell-O to simulate the parts of the cell. In order to do this, we had to punch a hole in the Ziploc holding the Jell-O and suspend it from the knob of a kitchen cabinet. We figured that once everything was assembled, we would refrigerate it over night and then move the solid mass into a fresh, un-punctured bag for travel and display purposes. Sam read off the candies and handed them to me so that I could push them down into the mushy, red Jell-O. Immediately, anything with a candy coating began to run; the M & M’s became a smear of opaque darkness, the Skittles blanched white and left a trail of dirty-looking Jell-O. The Airhead Extreme Golgi Body uncoiled immediately after being pushed into the depths, and my fingers left tunnels that did not seem to fill back in. The death blow was administered when I tried to insert the “nucleus,” which was a peach cut in half to reveal the pit. The directions called for a “plum or other stone fruit,” but there are no plums in Michigan in January, and I was damned lucky to have found a peach. It was, however, far too large, it displaced everything else and I had to pull it out, leaving a worse mess. “We could use an olive,” I suggested, rummaging in the refrigerator.

“But I’m supposed to be able to eat this after! I’m not eating Jell-O with candy and a green olive in it. Gross.”

I reminded myself that it was the learning that mattered, not the beauty of the project. I renewed my righteous indignation at having to do this ridiculous thing. I took a deep breath.”Okay,” I said evenly, “get me a Sharpie.” I drew a large black dot in the center of the biggest jawbreaker I could find, and pushed it into the middle of the “cell.” “Don’t eat that one” I told him.

It looked as if someone had eaten a great deal of candy and then vomited it, along with a pint of blood, into a Ziploc. It was unspeakable.

It did not ever “set,” really, and the next morning I sent Sam off to school on the bus with his disaster, secure in the knowledge that we had done our best, that he knew his stuff, and that no one could expect anybody to spend a lot of time, money and psychic energy on something so utterly ridiculous. On Facebook, the conversation continued; everyone else had driven their project to school. I sent the teacher a crisp but polite e-mail informing her that Sam had done his best, that I had done my best, that we had planned well and executed timely, but that I certainly hoped that she recognized that the content was much more important than the perfection of the finished product.

Around 11:30, we received a text from Sam. “Well that was a fale.” He came home that afternoon and told us that everyone else had come in with a better project, and that he was so thrown by the fact that his was so terrible that he was unable to remember all the parts of a cell. He had tried to make a joke out of it to save face; the teacher had told him to “sit down.” I received an equally crisp reply from the teacher telling me that the appearance of the completed project was not part of the grade rubric, but that because Sam had not correctly listed all parts of the cell, his grade was…bad.

Sam’s semester grade did not change; it was okay to start with, and it still is. I am a bad mother, and I understand that, going forward, I need to be more on top of these projects and to keep up with the Joneses, a group that apparently includes everybody but us. I would not, however, trade for anything in the world the fun I had with Sam making that disastrous bag of garbage, or how hard we laughed when we decided that it looked like nothing so much as a Ziploc full of vomit. Lessons learned.


Photo Credits:

Fast Times pizza delivery: http://www3.whig.com/whig/blogs/ihavealottoshare/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/123046__fast_times_l.jpg

Animal Cell: http://homepage.smc.edu/wissmann_paul/cell/animalcell.jpg

Jell-O: http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00032DOXA.01-A3CDPEGSIQM61V._SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg

Advertisements

About imagineannie

I feel like I'm fifteen - does that count? I'm lots of things, I get paid to be the Managing Editor for a local news publication, and I love my job. I am also inordinately fond of reading, animals (I have four), elephants, owls, hedgehogs writing, tramping in the woods, cooking India, Ireland, England, avocado toast, Sherlock Holmes, Harry Potter, Little Women, Fun Home, Lumber Janes, Fangirl, magic, Neil Gaiman, Jane Austen, YA books, not YA books, classical music, Salinger (OMG SALINGER), Brahms, key lime pie, indie music, podcasts, sleeping in, road trips, marmalade, museums, bookstores, the Oxford comma, BBC, The Miss Fisher Mysteries, birdwatching, seashells, kombucha, and stickers. Not a huge fan of chewing gum, jazz, trucker hats or dystopian and/or post-apolcalyptic fiction (but I'll try anything).

16 responses »

  1. Ann,

    Sounds like this all stems from you not teacheing Sam to like the flavor of Plaster of Paris at a much earlier age. Shame…..

    Reply
  2. I feel I should apologize. It really did work when we did it. Altho my progeny did not have to eat hers. The Sister-in Law

    Reply
    • Also, we used all light jello, we didn’t have to resort to red. My candy still bled though, but at least my teacher was a lovely perosn

      Reply
    • No apologies needed – you saved me from sending pizza to school!!!! (I don’t think he actually ate it anyway, after all that). Sarah, we probably could have used your help….

      Reply
  3. Ann – Thank you SO MUCH for sharing the story with your blog-world. It is rare that I laugh out loud while reading something (especially when I am alone) – but you had me rolling. The only thing missing from the blog was a picture of the completed “project” – guess I’ll have to check out FB to see if it made it there.

    Hope you take comfort in knowing that you are NEVER alone, and that most people, parents, OK mothers, just don’t talk (or laugh) about it.

    Thanks for making my day happier….
    Jodi

    Reply
    • I’m so glad you liked it. i had to recover from my deep and abiding shame before I could confess.

      There is no photographic evidence. We destroyed it all, in case Child Protective Services called….

      Reply
  4. Oh Ann-this is so funny. And you’re right–the memories you have from this project trump a mediocre grade from a questionable teaching person. Too bad Sam got flustered at the critical moment (but it happens to all of us, for sure) but you know and he knows that he really does know all the parts of a cell, and if he becomes a doctor or a biologist or the like, he has a great story to tell how he learned the parts of a human cell. Priceless.

    Reply
  5. I’ve always wondered about the purpose of these kinds of school projects. Are they for the student to learn? Are they to force the parents to be involved?

    Reply
  6. Honestly Ann, in 20 years, you and Sam will be talking about this and laughing about it! I think it will be a wonderful memory. It was VERY helpful for me to “hear” the conversation on Facebook, after I saw the jello post I googled it and found other ideas which helped us come up with something that worked for Daniel. His requirements were slightly different than the others. I still LOVE the pizza idea and it could have been a really cool cell.

    I tried to post a picture here of Daniel’s cell, but I couldn’t figure it out. It is oddly in my “weird squirrel album” on facebook 😉 This was very funny. By the way, while Daniel and I were working on this I found out he knew the parts of the cell but not what a cell actually “is”….lol so much for that.

    Reply
    • I’m glad the fb conversation helped; I think I would have been smarter to have stuck with the pizza. Honestly, I thought that was “slacking” and that we needed to work harder. In reality, if I had just brought in a pizza, Sam would have had a better project, been more confident, and done better.

      I am going to check out Daniel’s cell. I am laughing out loud that he knows the parts but not what a cell is, although you know, I bet he’s not the only one….

      Reply
  7. Ann, I LOVE your post about the cell. It was fabulous, funny, touching, imaginative, sweet and perfect.

    I think that Sam not only learned the parts of the cell but also learned another valuable lesson about how wonderful it is to have a caring and responsible mother to help him through these school projects. The lesson is to have the kids figure these things out while talking it out with a seasoned adult. Sam did this. In my mind, he deserved an A+ both for the idea, the hilarious mess and putting in so much time and thought. I can see how it would be intimidating to try and “keep up with some of these Jones’s” around here – yikes!!!!!

    Sure, any mother can bake a cake, decorate it to perfection and “chair it high above head through the market place” but is that really instilling a lesson? I think not.

    The good majority of people I see at both Marble, Glen Cairn, McDonald and East Lansing HS are overly involved in said projects and also with what is going on with this child and that child. What lessons are left to learn?

    I would give Sam an A for this project and smile that he has memories of this to last a lifetime.

    Good job!!! You are a WONDERFUL mother!!!!!!!

    Reply
    • Thanks Jen, although I have to tell you that a) Sam had NO ideas besides “you figure it out, mom” and b) the little cake maker of Shaw Estates did everything herself, from planning to frosting. Sam is a total slacker, except for the fact that he actually knew the material. (And yes, there were parents who did most of the work on the “perfect” projects, and in East lansing, there always will be).

      You make a good point, and I think the best teachers know exactly what’s going on. This, unfortunately, is not one of the best in that department.

      Thanks again. 🙂

      Reply
  8. I’m in the middle of dealing with this now! I’m an English teacher and hate science fair projects. Ugh!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: